Quick Read
- The House rejected Rep. Robert Nazal’s motion to reconsider the 2027 budget bill by voice vote on Nov. 10, so the Senate receives the bill as passed.
- Senate Finance Chair JV Ejercito has said House-added DPWH projects without complete documents will be removed before plenary debate.
- Only 1,418 of 16,244 DPWH projects had supporting documents submitted to the Senate at its Oct. 26 review.
- Contractors and proponents behind the 6,271 House-added lines carry the cost when DPWH project documents are missing.
The House declined to reopen the 2027 budget on Nov. 10, and that leaves the Senate to decide which DPWH projects stay in the bill. Members rejected, by voice vote, a motion to reconsider House Bill 10858, so the ₱7.2 trillion bill went to the Senate as passed. There, Senate Finance Chair JV Ejercito has said that projects without complete DPWH project documents will be removed before plenary debate.

Only Majority Voters Could Ask the House to Reconsider
Rep. Robert Nazal of Bagong Henerasyon first moved to reconsider the bill on Nov. 9, and the motion was set aside until plenary sessions resumed the next afternoon. Las Piñas Rep. Mark Anthony Santos objected, and Deputy Speaker Yevgeny Emano put the question to a voice vote. More members voted no, and no tally was given. Nazal’s motion aimed at provisions that critics warned could violate the guidelines set in the Supreme Court’s ruling on past budgets.
Section 105 of the House rules lets only members who voted with the majority move to reconsider an approved measure. House Bill 10858 passed on Oct. 12 by 281 to 13, with one abstention, so the 13 members who voted no were not eligible to file. The majority that passed the bill was the only group that could reopen it, and it chose not to. Nazal, who voted for the bill, then asked that his proposed amendments go to the Senate, which leaves any fixes to the other chamber.
The Senate Is Cutting Projects That Lack DPWH Project Documents
The Senate finance committee’s comparative review found that DPWH projects rose from 11,420 in the executive’s proposal to 16,244 in the House bill, including 6,271 projects that were not in the executive’s original submission. At the committee’s Oct. 26 review, only 1,418 of the 16,244 had supporting documents submitted to the Senate. The other 14,826, or 91.27 percent, had none on file at that point.
Ejercito gave DPWH until Nov. 3 to submit the complete DPWH project documents and justifications for the 6,271 House-added projects, and he warned that projects falling short would be removed before plenary debate. DPWH agreed to drop projects with incomplete requirements, and the Senate majority bloc has backed the effort. The Senate has also moved to remove 295 projects worth ₱8.8 billion from the executive’s own proposal after the former public works secretary told senators they lacked required documents. Ejercito has said the Senate will reject any project missing the requirements, whether it came from DPWH, the House or later Senate amendments. He is now running a line-by-line review, and he has said no project should be funded without complete supporting documents and proof that it can be implemented.
The paper standard is not new. DPWH told lawmakers that proposals for the 2027 budget must carry an approved program of work, validated geotagged photos, compliance with Budget Preparation Form 202, a certificate of implementability, and an endorsement from a regional or local development council. Projects the House added came in after that filter, so the Senate is applying the same DPWH project documents as its cutoff.
The Court Narrowed What the Bicameral Conference Can Do
In its October ruling, a 121-page decision that drew 12 separate opinions, the Supreme Court voided a ₱449.5 billion congressional increase in 2024 unprogrammed appropriations and a ₱17.99 billion increase in the DPWH Special Road Fund for 2025. It also invalidated two 2026 provisions on releasing unprogrammed funds. The Court limited the bicameral conference committee to reconciling differences between the House and Senate versions, and it said unprogrammed appropriations are not inherently unconstitutional.
The Solicitor General filed an 85-page motion for clarification and partial reconsideration on Nov. 4, so the decision is not yet final. Whether the ruling reaches the 2027 additions is unsettled, because the House kept the executive’s ₱7.2 trillion total. For the 2024 and 2025 budgets, the Court preserved limited effects for completed programs whose beneficiaries acted in good faith.
If the Court’s limit on the committee holds, a line that is identical in both versions is not a difference the committee can reopen. That makes the Senate’s version the place where undocumented lines come out, and it gives DPWH project documents their value before the bicameral conference opens, not after.
A Crowded Senate Calendar Raises the Stakes
Ejercito opposed sending the bill back to the House, saying a recall would leave a big chance the budget could not pass this year. The Senate has its own calendar problem. Ejercito could not file the committee report on the original date because the line-by-line review covers about 20,000 projects, and sponsorship is now set for Nov. 23, with the bicameral conference expected Dec. 10 to 12. Civil society groups are to be invited to observe the bicameral conference.
A reenacted budget leaves new 2027 line items unfunded. A House-added project without DPWH project documents therefore faces a cut if the Senate finishes on time and no funding if it does not. Ejercito has also urged lawmakers to protect major infrastructure such as the North-South Commuter Railway and the Metro Manila Subway.
The House passed the question to the Senate, and the Senate has made paper the price of staying in the bill. Contractors and proponents behind the 6,271 House-added lines carry that risk. The lines DPWH can document are the ones that reach the bicameral conference.
More developments that reshape the operating environment in National Signal section of Hemos PH.